It’s sometimes difficult being “just” a writer in a visual medium. Despite the fact that writers are the very foundation for those media (be they films, television, comics, video games, or something else), they’re often deeply in the shadows of the primary driver, which is what you can see, be it artwork or graphics or actors or whatever else is associated with your brand of storytelling. I remember Peter David, at the height of his fame as a writer on Incredible Hulk and several other Marvel titles, telling a story(!) about sitting at a convention and having a kid lead his mom up to David’s table and point him out as: “The writer. He’s the guy who puts all the words in the little bubbles.” But the fact is that all of those media are still methods of delivering a story and that story has to come from somewhere. As I’ve casually referred to in a couple other posts here, I am not an artist, so working in a medium that is most known for its art has always been a bit of a struggle because if I don’t have a cooperative partner, like Jeff, the stories I’m spinning and the worlds I’m exploring and the characters I’m creating have no outlet. They’re just shells, waiting to be brought to life by whoever can draw better than stick figures (i.e. most other people who aren’t me.) This was a regular issue at Fifth Panel Comics, because the vast majority of the people who participated in the studio with us were writer/artists. They came to us with stories ready to go, which they had (sometimes) written and with artwork that revolved around those stories. Asking them to drop the vision that they came to us with and instead draw up someone else’s vision is a challenge; both for them and for us. That meant that a lot of the time I spent at 5PC was oriented around someone else’s work and that was a situation that came to a head around 1996, if I’m remembering it correctly.
We used to have regular, weekly meetings at a string of restaurants along Telegraph, south of 696. It was a relatively convenient locale for everyone because Jeff worked near there and Kevin and Nora (our one artist/writer combo) lived in Taylor and I could reach that area easily by coming down 96 from Ann Arbor (and was the one most willing to travel in those days.) Sometimes it would be a sitdown place. Other times it would be a fast food joint of some kind. I don’t remember the names of any of them because it’s been 30+ years and the locale was never important. It was the work. Always the work. At one of those meetings, we had already moved up in the publishing world and had begun doing full-sized comics, rather than the digest-sized productions we had been doing in earlier days. Our first release was an anthology title that would regularly collect the work of a few of our artists like Kevin, Dave Witt, and Todd Richards, telling their own stories and drawing their own panels. As an offhand comment the year before, I had suggested to Jeff that we call the book Razorwire: twisted, convoluted, cutting edge. He liked it and, thus, there it was. At the meeting in question, we were in one of the aforementioned fast food places, sitting in a booth, with a few copies of the first issue and some pages for the next one. One of the guys working behind the counter had overheard us and came up to our table and asked what we were working on.
We gladly showed him the first issue and Jeff asked if he wanted a copy. He nodded excitedly and then asked if we could sign the book. He looked at Jeff and said: “Who are you?” Jeff said: “I’m the publisher.” and scrawled his name. Then he turned to Kevin and Nora and they said: “I’m the artist on this story” and “I’m his writer on that story”, respectively. Then he turned to me and said: “And who are you?” I… had nothing to say. My name was nowhere on that book, even though I’d been deeply involved in its creation. I finally said: “I’m nobody.” And, a moment later, I shrugged and said: “I came up with the title.” He laughed and said: “Well, I’ll take your autograph, anyway.” Everyone laughed except me and I shrugged again and signed it. That stuck with me for a long time. It still kind of dwells with me to this day. I had spent five years with the studio, pushing things forward and doing all-nighters with Jeff and driving through ice storms because “This is when we work!” And when we finally got to the point that we were doing regular, full-sized comics, my work and my name was nowhere to be seen. From a publishing (and public) perspective, I didn’t exist. So, when we met up at a different restaurant the next time, after having that moment infesting my thoughts for a week, I told Jeff: “I have to go. I have to find somewhere where the stories I’m writing- have written -are actually going to be seen and read.” He knew exactly what I was talking about because, of course, he had started the studio in the first place because he was an artist and wanted to draw comics and yet basically hadn’t picked up a pencil except for the occasional promotional piece in years. He said: “I totally understand. Come up to our place this weekend. I have an idea that I want to pitch to you.”
At this moment, I knew that Jeff had two concerns. One of them was that I might be walking away feeling like I’d accomplished nothing, creatively, in the time I’d been with the studio. The other was that we were still no closer to generating anything even mildly profitable and it was Jeff’s money that was being poured down a hole to keep 5PC in business in a very crowded market. He wanted to produce something that would highlight both of us as actual creators, rather than editors (although editors can be and often are key members of the creative process) but he also wanted to produce something that might have a slight hope of catching the eye of readers so we could, y’know, make some money to pay off the mounting debts that the studio was generating. We sat down that weekend and he said: “I want to do a vampire book.” I immediately cringed. Vampires were still a relatively hot property at that point because of Anne Rice and the films made from her books, as well as White Wolf’s Vampire: The Masquerade series of RPGs. There was an instant audience for them that wouldn’t be present for my more, uh, esoteric material. But, he said, he wanted to do vampires in the future, so kind of a hi-tech, SF setting; distinct from the usual 19th-century-to-contemporaneous fare. He looked at me and said: “That’s the basic idea. I want you to run with it and see what you come up with.”
Ideas had never been an issue for me. I’ve mentioned before how Dystopia came to be a thing from some scattered notes and me sitting down in front of a keyboard for a couple hours. Jeff was expecting that I could do the same thing. The difference was that I didn’t want to do a vampire book. I didn’t want to do anything but what I had already written several hundred pages of script for. But I also realized, again, that he was in the same place that I was. He had to keep being the publisher because otherwise the whole thing would simply fall apart. But at least working on a creative concept between the two of us would give him a step back into that world that he had begun this project to do in the first place. So, we sat there for an hour or two and I just spieled out the basics of what would become Gothic, our other full-sized publication. I came up with the concept of vampires being a hereditary condition caused by other-dimensional beings mating/fusing with humanity; how there were four separate clans primarily based on the type of being that spawned them and, in the present time, based on the kind of thing that they fed upon from “regular” humans (blood, flesh, endorphins, mental energy (aka “souls.”), etc.) I tossed out a couple dozen characters: each clan had a prince, a savant (kind of a “best sorceror in the house”), and at least a couple praetors (executors of the prince’s will.) There was also the Cabal of the Flesh, the largest gathering of “witches” who were using the vampires’ own manipulation of energy (“magick”) against them by fusing it with technology. There were the human authorities in a dying world, strapped for oxygen, including one of the officers of the local domestic security/control forces, Jane Stasi. There’s a lot of backstory behind all of that that I just kind of rattled off and was tapping out notes for on my archaic laptop while Jeff just watched and smiled.
That’s how my process usually works. People will come up to me and say: “Tell me a story.” My usual response is: “I don’t know any stories.” But, give me the kernel of an idea, and I will usually build a story around it quite quickly. I don’t even need anyone else to proffer it, either. As I’ve mentioned before, sometimes I could just see a book cover or hear a news item and just start generating off of that. This was a project that I wasn’t excited about at all, but if it needed a story to go with it, I could do it and I did. The Gothic “bible” is only 1/4 the length of the one for Dystopia, but it still contains an entire world and a lot of broad concepts and fragments that could be built any way that we wanted to send it. In the end, we only got two issues produced before the comic industry and the studio imploded, but that was at least our attempt to bring some creativity back to the studio picture for Jeff and me. It wasn’t what I wanted to do. It probably wasn’t top on Jeff’s list of stories to tell, either. But it was something and was angled toward providing for the studio so that all of our creative ventures could go forward.
Now we have a very different reality. Jeff doesn’t need to pour money down a hole to keep us going since, for the relatively minor cost of a URL, we can produce comics in the format that many millions are already reading them on a regular basis and be sure that we’re reaching our readers. The ability to self-publish means that I could try to finish the serial novel that our current stories are based on, upload it to Amazon, and watch it take off like the Wool series. There are more ways forward than before and the fact that I’m still “just” a writer in this visual medium is much less of a concern than it was in the past. I have to say that I don’t know that I could replicate my old creative process, especially since the material that we’re working on now is at least 15 years old and based on concepts that are 30+ years old. We have a long way to go before I would have to sit down and spiel out an entire universe in an hour again. But the satisfaction comes in knowing that, finally, at least some of the stories and characters that have been living in my head for three decades will be seen by others; from me “putting the words in the bubbles” and Jeff putting faces to those words. It’s taken a long time, but it’s good to finally feel like a real member of the creative team.